
My relationship with X-Men: First Class was a weird one. I heard about the movie, got excited that it would feature the original X-Men, found out it wouldn’t and got disinterested, saw some early shots and thought it looked boring, watched the most recent trailer and thought there was some promise, heard early good reviews and was hopeful and then watched it for myself and was satisfied, but not blown away.
Let’s start with the good:
Magneto
I don’t think I’ve ever felt for Magneto’s plight. But seeing his torture at the Nazi’s hands and how he knew the humans would turn on them and them doing so, you really feel for him and his cause. I think Michael Fassbender does an amazing job and needs to be signed for a second film immediately.
Professor X
Equally impressive is James McAvoy as a young Professor X. None of the stately Patrick Stewart Professor X here. McAvoy’s Xavier has fun and has a youthful exuberance about him that is actually quite refreshing. The two characters definitely have chemistry with each other and play each other’s foils perfectly.
The amount of stuff they tried to pack into it
From Mystique appearing at Xavier’s at a young age, to finding mutants with Cerebro to Hank’s struggle with his mutant self to Moira MacTaggert playing a more prominent role – it’s clear that Matthew Vaughn decided to deviate from the source material quite early on and in some ways the show feels fresh because of it, in other ways it’s a worse movie because of it.
What I didn’t like
Sebastian Shaw
With no offence to Kevin Bacon, Sebastian Shaw was a weak character. In fact all the villains were poorly fleshed out. They try to build him up as a badass by killing Aaron Pierce (sorry, Colonel Hendry) and Darwin (which shouldn’t be possible), but then he’s just owned by Magneto. Weak. Also, the visual representation of his power was just unimpressive.
The other baddies
I had to Google to find out who Riptide was. He didn’t do anything worth mentioning and special mention to Azazel, your son, Nightcrawler, already did the whole BAMF in and out of a guarded facility in 2003 for X2. And it was better.
Team Selections
I think as a comic book fan, one big disappointment was the selection of the mutants who made up the teams:
- Beast (original X-Men)
- Banshee (2nd batch from Giant-Sized X-Men)
- Havok (who appeared along the way)
- Angel (from Grant Morrison’s run in the 2000′s)
- Darwin (from Ed Brubaker’s “Deadly Genesis” series in the late 2000′s)
And then of course you have Mystique, Azazel (from Chuck Austen’s terrible run) and Riptide (who does nothing). There’s no rhyme or reason for these particular mutants, none of the chemistry that existed between the original team or any of the later teams simply because these characters have never interacted with each other and there is no source material to base them on. None of the mutants get any screen time worth shouting about and Havok really looked lame using his powers like he was playing with a hula-hoop.
Continuity
I’m not HUGE on continuity but I like to know that my characters exist in the same universe (or that they don’t). This was touted as a prequel to the X-Men movies, yet clearly it exists on its own. I would have gotten a bigger kick seeing the layers peeled away in the Mystique/Magneto relationship to find out how she ends up on his side. Unfortunately, that never quite happens. It’s these little things that could have made the movie so much more, but didn’t.
I guess in closing, X-Men: First Class is a very solid movie. It could be a great movie about super-powered humans/mutants, but it is merely a mediocre X-Men movie.